Following the August discussion on operationalizing technical working groups (TWGs), the third meeting of the Digital Health Blueprint Toolkit Community of Practice (DHBT CoP) was held on 24 September 2026.

This meeting focused on costing and investment planning for Digital Health Blueprints.

Fifteen members of the Community from nine countries participated. The meeting opened with a technical refresher from the World Bank on the investment rationale and the Blueprint Toolkit’s costing template. This was followed by members from Saint Lucia and Indonesia sharing their countries’ experiences with costing.

Refresher: Investment Rationale for National Digital Health Blueprints

Ali Habib, Senior Digital Health Specialist from the World Bank gave a refresher presentation on the Toolkit’s investment rationale and corresponding template, also known as the costing tool. He clarified that the investment rationale is not a budget but a 10-year cost estimation for financial planning.

More guidance is available in the Toolkit’s how-to guide: https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/b929829fc3d36bebdf9d93555c64f222-0140022024/related/Digital-Health-Blueprint-Toolkit-How-To-Guide.pdf

Disease Burden

Ali reminded the CoP that costing should be grounded in disease burden, which will inform the potential return of investment. The disease burden is determined in Workshop 1 and later feeds the return on investment calculation. The top five or top ten disease burdens, based on the Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs), are accessible via the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) for most countries.

Through the sensitivity analysis, the health outcome improvement is linked to the potential economic value to be gained. For the purposes of the costing, one DALY is treated as one Quality Adjusted Life Year(QALY) gained. The underlying theory is that improving the quality of care can reduce disease burden or DALYs, resulting in corresponding economic gain as a healthier population contributes to improved GDP.

Using the Costing Template: Inputs

Rather than waiting until the end of the process and running the risk of losing track of relevant information, Ali advised collecting costing inputs during Workshops 1-4. Some of the inputs include the following:

  • Current population and growth rate
  • Number of health workers and growth rate
  • Number and types of health facilities and facility growth rate
  • Inflation or cost escalation
  • Total health expenditure per capita (may be obtained from the World Bank website)

Important tips!

  • Only populate the green cells in the spreadsheet. Everything else automatically calculates.
  • Group facilities by implementation complexity — meaning how much it costs to implement — rather than by facility type. To illustrate, a very large primary care centre may be as complex to implement as a medium-sized hospital, while a small hospital maybe easier.
  • If growth rates are unknown for facilities and health workers, enter the ideal rates based on needs rather than the actual rates.

Using the Costing Template: Components

Costing is split into separate components so that each can be handled one at a time. The template contains the following costing components expressed as Excel tabs:

  • Governance: Captures the resources required to set up governance for digital health. At a high level, activity-based orone-off costs pertain to the development of strategies, blueprints, specification, data policies, and other governance-relatedactivities. Ongoing costs include salaries for the digital health governance staff (this refers to people whose specific responsibility is to steward digital health in the country, and should be differentiated from staff who are simply performing digital-healthgovernance activities in addition to their other jobs), meeting expenses, and other routine operational costs for maintaining a governance function.
  • Data Centre: Estimates the cost of hosting and deploying the HIE components. It does not refer to the cost of building a physical data centre in the country from scratch. Instead, the costing focuses on setting up, deploying, and maintaining HIE components in the chosen hosting environment, which could be a cloud infrastructure, a national data centre, or another existing server environment.
  • Client Registry: Focuses on the cost of creating and maintaining an ID for each individual (physical or digital), including factors such as the number of issuing facilities for IDs and associated costs for equipping and maintaining them. It’s important to consider if existing identification schemes have been identified in the country.
  • Facility Registry: Focuses on the cost of connecting different data sources required to set up and maintain information on facilities. Costing should consider the number of existing data sources and associated costs for establishing and maintaining data exchange among data sources.
  • Health Worker Registry: Works the same way as the facility registry but centers on data sources with health worker-relatedinformation. The costs cover separate licensing databases for doctors, nurses, and other professions, each feeding the registry.
  • Shared Health Record: Moves costing towards implementing different applications at the health facilities. The tab captures setup and maintenance costs, the percentage the Ministry of Health pays when the private sector is involved, set-up and operating costs by facility type, facilities already equipped that can be excluded, and the time needed for rollout.
  • Terminology Services: Estimates the costs for licensing terminology databases, and ensuring they are connected to the architecture and remain up to date.
  • Health Management Information System: Also identifies what health management information systems are already in place, and estimates costs associated with connecting, maintaining and using them within the digital health environment.
  • Human Resources for Health Capacity: Estimates costs for required capacity-building for human resources for health. Even with an HIE set up, if there is no capacity building in the health workforce, no one will be able to use digital tools as planned.
  • Cost Utility Analysis: Provides an analysis of economic gain based on improved disease burden. Users will enter the top five disease burdens, the number of years to scale nationwide, and the expected impact on disease burden. It has been recommended to start with 1% as a baseline, noting that if a 1% impact is not credible, there is little point in starting.

Important tips!

  • Distinguish between upfront costs (capital expenditure) and ongoing costs (operational expenditure).
  • Consider existing investments to leverage, policy and legislation gaps to address, and existing data sources to use.
  • Use ballpark estimates rather than getting the exact numbers for the costing pieces.

Return on Investment

To conclude, Ali emphasized that the investment rationale can contribute to justifying funding-related requests to Ministry leaders, donors, lenders, and other partners. It builds the case for a national digital health budget, makes stronger funding requests to partners, and helps prepare for financing from multilateral partners (e.g., development banks).

To date, 11 countries have used the Toolkit. Ali noted that even at a 1% impact on disease burden, most countries they have worked with could see a return on investment in year 4 or 5 out of the 10-year cost estimation.

For senior leaders, the key message is that digital health is a long-term investment. Costs start immediately but benefits take time to materialize. The costing tool can be used to inform funding and project the return on investment for a national digital health initiative, not predict benefits.

Saint Lucia’s Costing Experience: NCD Project leveraging Digital Health

Ira Azela Leonora Isaacs, Regional Quality Expert – Caribbean, presented how Saint Lucia used costing to support a Korea-World Bank Partnership Facility (KWPF) initiative to improve non-communicable disease (NCD) care through digital health. The investment case enabled Saint Lucia to scope the Digital Health Blueprint into a 24-month NCD project, allowing senior leadership and funders to understand the costs of piloting the initiative and inform scale-up. Derived from the Digital Health Blueprint, this newly introduced project will serve as a pilot to inform future evaluation and improvements.

“Resource mobilization translated our digital health needs into investment language for governments and partners to understand.”

Adaptation Process

  1. Define priority use cases: Saint Lucia began by defining priority use cases, including diabetes, hypertension, stroke, and continuity of care. 
  2. Review readiness: Readiness across current and desired systems, infrastructure, data, workforce, and governance, were reviewed.
  3. Categorise facilities: Facility categories and their varying needs were also identified.
  4. Build cost assumptions: Based on these categories, Saint Lucia developed cost assumptions covering capital and operational expenditures. For example, the costing exercise helped identify the need for additional roles, such as an AI specialist in later phases, while prioritizing a data analyst in the immediate term. Benefits, drawbacks, and legislative requirements for cloud hosting were also assessed.
  5. Phase the investments: Saint Lucia phased both assumptions and costs. For example, on interoperability, they considered the tools needed for integration, optimization, and analytics over the 10-year period and adopted the FHIR standard.
  6. Review and refine: Assumptions were further refined through further review with the governance body.

Challenges

  • Incomplete baseline data
  • Unit cost vs. total cost
  • Recurrent costs
  • Uncertain architecture choices
  • Private sector participation

Lessons Learned

  • Start with readiness
  • Make assumptions visible
  • Plan for sustainability
  • Cost by facility type
  • Keep it iterative

Recommendations

  • Begin with a readiness baseline: Inventory systems, infrastructure, connectivity, workforce and governance gaps before pricing.
  • Separate “must-have” from “nice-to-have”: Protect foundational investments from being diluted by wish-list items.
  • Build facility categories early: Cost hospitals, PHC, specialized services and private/ancillary providers differently.
  • Show capital expenditure (CapEx) and operational expenditure (OpEx clearly): Decision-makers need to see what is purchased once and what must be sustained annually.
  • Document every assumption: Scope, quantities, unit costs, exchange rates, contingencies and dependencies should be visible.
  • Use the plan for dialogue: The investment plan is a conversation tool for finance, procurement, ICT, health services and partners.

Indonesia’s Costing Experience: Digital Health Transformation Strategy 2.0

Regina Manjali, Consultant from the World Bank discussed the costing experience for Indonesia’s Digital Health Transformation Strategy (DHTS) 2.0. The World Bank is supporting the development of costing exercises to Indonesia’s DHTS 2.0 along with the British Embassy, AMANA Solutions and Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM).

“For Indonesia, the value of costing is not only knowing ‘how much DHTS costs.’ It is creating a structured conversation about what we need to invest in, which assumptions matter, who should finance it, and how the strategy can move into actual planning and budgeting.”

Adaptation Process

  • Activity-Based Costing: The financing requirements for the 2025–2029 DHTS roadmap were estimated using the Activity-Based Costing (ABC) method.
  • Categorization of Digital Health: The costing categorized digital health activities by missions, focus areas, and investment categories, drawing on the previous experience with the Digital Health Transformation Strategy 1.0 and previous government evaluations.
  • Yearly Activity Planning: Costs were then calculated based on activities planned for each year, from 2025 to 2029.
  • Inclusions in the Scope of the Cost Requirements Analysis: The costing focused on digital health activities that support programme indicators and are implemented by the Ministry of Health and its direct network, including local health offices and health facilities such as hospitals, Puskesmas, clinics, blood transfusion units, and laboratories. Identified private-sector roles related to health facilities were also included, along with operational costs such as internet subscriptions and electricity.
  • Exclusions in the Scope of the Cost Requirements Analysis: Meanwhile, the costing excluded enabling infrastructure for digitalization, digital public infrastructure (DPI) provided by other ministries or agencies, such as regional internet connectivity and civil registration services. It also excludes National Health Insurance and its related investments, and other government institutions not directly related to the health sector, such as the National Procurement Agency and the National Investment Agency.

Challenges and Lessons Learned

  • Clear scope and boundaries are essential for a meaningful costing exercise.
  • Reliable cost data are not always readily available.
  • Costing is a moving target when the strategy is still evolving.

Recommendations

  • Start costing while developing the implementation roadmap—not after it is finished: Doing both together forces strategic activities to become more concrete and exposes implementation assumptions early.
  • Adapt the Toolkit rather than applying it mechanically: Use the Blueprint Toolkit to create a common investment structure, but map it to the country’s own health-system architecture, financing arrangements, and public financial management system.
  • Spend more time validating the largest cost drivers than perfecting every line item: A few assumptions—such as infrastructure, storage, number of facilities, or system deployment models—can drive a very large share of the total estimate. These deserve the greatest scrutiny.
  • Design the costing as a living tool: The first estimate will never contain perfect information. What matters is having transparent assumptions, identifying which assumptions require further validation, assigning ownership for updating them, and connecting future updates to the planning and budgeting cycle.

Additional insights shared

  • Start costing early: In Arusha, introducing costing from the outset helped participants connect inputs from earlier workshops and made the exercise more manageable.
  • Treat costing as an iterative exercise: The goal is not to get the numbers “right,” but to make them as realistic as possible. Document assumptions and the rationale behind changes.
  • Use the costing to prioritize: Costing can help countries identify what to fund first and make stronger resource-mobilization cases.
  • Link costing to implementation: In Saint Lucia, the Blueprint and costing helped translate the broader digital health vision into a focused NCD initiative and a 24-month pilot, with a pathway to scale.
  • Make the materials work for different audiences: The “Amar” story and patient journey were successfully adapted for a connectathon in the Phuiland helped communicate the value of digital health to finance and policy teams.
  • Learn from different country approaches: Indonesia and Saint Lucia applied the costing process differently, highlighting the flexibility of the Toolkit and the value of country-to-country learning.
  • Suggestion for potential tool enhancement: Adding a dedicated tab to document the assumptions behind the calculations has been suggested.